FAQ
Do you buy cards?
Yes, we do buy sports and TCG cards! Whether you have individual cards or entire collections, we're interested in purchasing them
Do you trade?
We do offer trades.
Do you host events or trading nights?
Yes, we host monthly events and trading nights for collectors! It's an excellent opportunity to meet fellow collectors, trade cards, and participate in giveaways and limited time discounts.
Can I sell my cards online through your store?
At the moment, we primarily buy at our brick-and-mortar store and at card shows. However, we're working on expanding our online presence, so stay tuned for updates regarding online selling options.
When’s the best time to come in to sell or trade-in my cards?
We currently buy and accept trades 7 days a week during our normal business hours! However, we do recommend checking our social media or calling before you come in to be sure we are currently buying.
Do you grade cards?
Sorry we do not grade cards
Do you sell gift cards?
Yes we sell Gift Cards In Store Only
What are your store hours?
Monday-Thursday: 11AM-6PM
Friday: 11AM-8PM
Saturday & Sunday: 11AM-3PM
Where is your store located?
We are located at 500 Plaza Dr. Suite 3A, Carterville IL. 62918. We are down from Dairy Queen and McDonalds.
Will the owner be there when I come in?
Jason is around the store quite often, however we cannot guarantee his schedule availability for when you choose to visit.
Let customers speak for us
from 22 reviewsI visited this shop with my daughter a few weeks ago, and we loved it. It's very nicely set up, and the owner is very friendly. They have a little bit of everything! Very reasonable prices too!
Jason does a great job of engaging with his customers and making you feel welcome! He keeps the hobby fun the way it should be! Definitely check out his shop if you haven't already
So where to start…
1.)Great product diversity!!! Every time I come in there is something new.
2.)Friendly staff. Jason and Austin are both extremely kind and courteous to visitors arriving to the shop.
3.) Knowledgeable. Jason is very knowledgeable about his products and products you bring in. Additionally he is willing to share that knowledge and educate collectors of all ages. Jason is also willing to learn new information.
4.) Puts the customer 1st. This has been demonstrated many different times in different ways since the shop opened. From recommendations for grading, special ordering items, free cards for kids, and Family Break Night & Trade Night. Cardfather Sports Cards true gives the community everything they have.
I highly recommend stopping by. Even if you don’t buy something Jason and Austin are great conversations and you will leave with something!!!Thanks for everything you guys do!!!
Doesn't tip toe around feelings or facts
Nice finding a product locally that I know I can trust.

Great card shop! Owner is very pleasant to work with. The store is very organized. Easy to browse the selection. No pressure, very pleasant experience to browse the cards. Great conversation with the staff. I’ll definitely return. The owner is a true collector and not just another resale shop.
Recently I stumbled (not literally) upon this store while shopping online (actually, via an app) and ordered a set of 500 sleeves (nothing fancy) because who doesn't like a great sale on something you can use for gaming? Within moments, I was notified via a phone message and email that the item in question was OOS. Bummer, right? No. Stop the press! I was offered a better brand of soft sleeves -- Easy Glide Premium in their stead. How could I refuse an offer like that?! Needless to say, after receiving the sleeves, I believe I'm in love (again, not literally) and heavily enthusiastic about the sleeves which will now go on one of my newer board games. Only the best for the best. Likewise, shipping was great. Sturdy box, bubble wrap layered around the sleeve packs (there were 5 total). Great tracking info sent b/c I set that up via the USPS. What else can I say here? I will definitely be a returning customer in the near future.
If you have any interest in card collecting in the southern Illinois area come check it
My boys and I love coming to this store. Jason has helped with our knowledge about collecting and is always happy to answer the questions of pre-teen boys . They would probably live there if he would let them. Not to mention they love the video games and taking part in his family breaks.
This card store is one of the best I've been to probably my favorite one if I was to choose between them all!!!. The owner is amazing and nice he treats everyone with respect and is a good person to talk to. Him and his store are really amazing!!! I recommend stopping by you won't regret it.👍